That’s what I’ve been wondering ever since I read a review of Chris Mooney’s new book, The Republican Brain: The Science of Why They Deny Science — and Reality. Now, before you get in a tizzy over the subtitle, take a deep breath and think about horses grazing in a field.
There, that’s better, isn’t it?
If you’re a Conservative, you can relax, because despite the title of Mooney’s book, it looks like you and your horse are on the same page. At least when it comes to amygdalas.
In case you didn’t know, the amydgala is where “the fight or flight reflex” is housed. And while I can’t tell you how the relative size of the equine amygdala compares to ours (can someone enlighten me?), I can tell you that the equine amygdala as a percentage of cerebral volume is higher than that of a cow or a pig.
However, when it comes to Elephants and Donkeys, it’s even more enlightening. It turns out that the amydgalas of Conservatives are bigger than those of Liberals. The “startle reflexes” of Conservatives are also keener, it is said.
Drawing on neuroscience, linguistics and experimental psychology, author Mooney informs his readers that the tolerance of ambiguity and an urge to cogitate are core Liberal traits, while resistance to change and a need for closure are core Conservative traits. Which sounds more like your horse?
I’ve known horses who must be Conservatives and horses that must be Liberals. And I’ve known Conservatives and Liberals that I thought of as one specific area of a horse…
If you’re a Conservative, sharing a larger amygdala with your horse will probably make you feel even closer, and you can rekindle a kinship with all equines in good faith. If you’re a Liberal, your heart is probably bleeding for all the horses who are mistreated and misunderstood, and you may even be hoping that your horse, no matter how set in his ways he is, will change the way he thinks and behaves if you work hard enough at it (and you’re probably right on that count).
Politics aside, what’s most intriguing to me is the brain science here. It bodes well as a line of inquiry for the future, but I think if we want to make real progress, our focus should shift from the human brain to the equine brain.
When we discover where tolerance resides in the horse’s brain — and we know it’s in there because look at what they tolerate from us — I won’t be surprised to hear that the area is larger in size, on a relative basis, than it is in our own brains. Until then, we can at least try to model ourselves after our four-legged friends in the barn.
MoniqueVGL said:
Great post, that was fun to read. And will have to share this with my politically engaged horse friends.
LikeLike
Katie said:
Glad you liked it! You probably already have noticed this, but there are lots of “instant” share options at the bottom of the post.
LikeLike
MoniqueVGL said:
Yes, and I have used those!
LikeLike
Calm, Forward, Straight said:
I wonder if the terms liberal and conservative have strayed from their origins, or perhaps gotten charged with extra “meaning” – in the political context at least…
Katie – I wanted to thank you for your recent comment over at my blog. I am dedicated to getting the basics down, though Val and I are taking our sweet time about it. I am still searching for a video camera (not a point and shoot that can sort of do video), and look forward to opportunities for lessons as soon as I find the right model. I certainly appreciate you stopping by. 🙂
LikeLike
Katie said:
I appreciate you sharing your thoughts, incisive as usual. I do think that the political labels have gotten quite muddied. It would be interesting to read the book I referenced, but I’m not sure I will…I trust my readers will take it all with a grain of salt, as I did…but the “thumbnail” psychology did make me think about horses (of course, almost everything makes me think of horses!).
I enjoy your blog and reading about your relationship with your horse. The basics that you’re working on are hard to do well, but fixing them later is so much harder. So, I say “Bravo!”
LikeLike