The 33-year old horse who boards with us is quite the character. And my Yankee-Irish horse whispering boyfriend has become even more attached to him since I broke my back, and he single-handedly assumed all the barn chores. (I’m better now, but I still can’t lift a water bucket, much less a muck bucket).
Like any good horseman, my boyfriend has a very good eye. He observes. And he files those observations away for future reference.
Like me, he thinks that horses understand what we say. Not just our intent and our thoughts, but our words as well.
Recently, he observed our 33-year old retiree having a bit more difficulty getting up after rolling in the paddock. We discussed the matter, and our decision to call the horse’s owner to discuss our concerns, all within earshot of the horses in turnout.
Within days, our retiree had developed a new habit. Every night after his dinner of mash, he would roll. He made sure to drop to his knees while my boyfriend was still in the stall, picking manure apples out of the straw. My boyfriend would have to stop, move aside and observe, while our retiree flung his body against the fluffy banks.
My boyfriend told me about this new activity (so I, too, could observe and file away). The horse seemed free of discomfort. Nothing even vaguely resembled colic. It was just a new and unusual habit.
His owner decided to put him on Cosequin ASU for a month, and see if it helped lubricate his movement. Actually, he looks pretty amazing, especially when he does a medium trot or half-pass of his own accord.
Still, he enjoyed a dinner roll every night. That is, until last week, when he suddenly stopped. Why? Who knows, but my boyfriend has a theory. He thought back to when the habit began, when our retiree overheard us discussing our concerns about him being able to get up after rolling in the less accommodating footing this winter. My boyfriend hypothesized that our retiree’s nightly dinner roll was a demonstration that not only could he still roll, he could get up every time.
So my boyfriend decided to say something about it. Last Tuesday, during dinner with the horse, he said, “Zack, you don’t need to show me that you can still roll and get up. It’s all right. I know you can.”
Perhaps it was simply serendipity, the curious phenomenon that Arthur Koestler discusses in his marvelous book, The Roots of Coincidence. Or perhaps horses really do speak English. At least, it seems, our 33-year old retiree does. Because he no longer finds the necessity of adding a dinner roll to his nightly diet.
Do you think your horse understands every word you say? Or simply your intent? Do you think a horse has a limited vocabulary? Or do you suspect that, as it was with elephants, our limited estimation of their communication skills has more to do with our own limitations than it does with theirs?
Not intending to be a comment pest, but this subject is a particular “hobby horse” of mine (posted on it a couple of weeks ago). My two French horses many years ago adapted to English words and phrases – not just the sounds – fairly quickly and my little PRE is just about tri-lingual now (raised in Spain, imported to France, working for a Brit!). I’m not saying we have philisophical discussions, but with their fine hearing and interpretive prey skills, why wouldn’t it be in horses’ interest to understand their people, especially if, like Zack you’ve had 33 years to get the hang of it. Glad he lives with people who are sensible enough to listen! Will your back get better, I hope so?
LikeLike
We love lots of comments here! It makes the discussion more informative and interesting for everyone. Can you link me to your post on the topic or give me the title? I love the fact that your horses are “just about try-lingual now”!
Thanks for inquiring about my back, and for your concern. My back is fine now, and stays fine as long as I do my exercises and don’t lift too much weight. Now I have another incentive to increase suppleness in any horse I ride.
LikeLike
The last time I trimmed Gwen’s feet I was getting ready to finish up her right hind. It was on the ground so I said to her, “I’m almost done I just have to finish the left side of this foot.” She picked up her left hind. So I said, “Oops, sorry, I need the right hind for this.” She put down her left and picked up her right. Absolutely true story.
LikeLike
What a great story. Thanks for sharing that, Shannon.
LikeLike
Having cared for my own horses at home for over 34yrs. I can honestly say, they understand every word I speak. I carry on a conversation to both the horses and the goats just like I would to a person. Especially when riding in the woods. And I sing when I ride: reactions have been favorable. lol Also, I had an animal communicator speak with me and my pinto Dini. She told me things that she couldn’t have known except thru Dini. She spoke to him in English, so I have to assume he understands the language.
LikeLike
So far, it’s unanimous! Thanks for your contribution to the discussion, Elaine.
LikeLike
Could it even be that the horses are catching the thought waves before they even leave our mouths ;-} The post I did was Walking the walk..and talking the talk? in early Dec. on cavaliereattitude – partly prompted by an article in the French mag. I subscribe to, in which various well-known trainers gave their conflicting views, (some maintained speech undermined the subtlety of their body language, others that horses felt safer in silence so they could listen out for prey) and after a long period when being grounded due to injury reinforced my own experiences – pro “conversation” – and gave me plenty of pause for thought!
LikeLike
Yes, I suspect that horses catch our intent before the words leave our mouths, because I think they may be quicker to process the subtle cues that we unknowingly communicate than we are…and we likely betray them before we open our mouths to speak.
I just finished reading your post on the topic — wonderful thoughts.
I worked extensively with a prominent natural horsemanship trainer who is very anti-voice and who cited the same reasons you cited above. As with everything I’ve been taught by my mentors, I try it before I decide I like it (or not).
Having a moratorium on using voice made me more conscious of when I used my voice, and I think made me more aware of making my words count, although I’ve never been one for “baby talk” or stream of consciousness around the horses.
Right now, I find myself in a place where I believe the voice is a means of communication we shouldn’t overlook, if we want to be friends with our horses. It’s also a wonderful aid, and should be used with care and consideration, as we do all our aids.
LikeLike
Let’s not forget that in the bible we are told that before we lost paradise man could literally speak with all the animals. Just because we are now mute with each other doesn’t mean that the horse has forgotten our language.
LikeLike
I think both Katie and Elaine’s latest observations bring together the poetry and prose of our daily dealings with our horses. Respect, consideration, subtlety and being true to your own beliefs and feelings … an inspiring and polyvalent creed! Thanks to Katie, Elaine and Shannon
LikeLike
Thanks cavalierattitude (love your sign on). It’s nice to have you posting.
LikeLike