It takes an embarrassingly long amount of time to find a saddle that fits. No other proof is needed beyond the time elapsed between this post and the post you’re reading now.
I didn’t just sit on my hay bales in the meantime. Far from it. About two hundred feet, in fact, on the chair in front of my computer, emailing saddle fitters and friends for suggestions and advice, and searching for a new saddle through my favorite online sources: Trumbull Mountain, fineusedsaddles.com, Rick’s Heritage Saddlery, Pelham Saddlery, and, of course, ebay.

Kent & Masters
The local saddle fitter I’ve been using asked me about my budget (answer: getting smaller by the minute) and, remembering what I like, suggested a new Kent & Masters (“under $2000, all leather, wool flocked, interchangeable gullet system, simple seat, simple saddle”) that I could try. I replied that I would never, ever again buy a custom (read: “new”) saddle again.
I reached out to one of my friends, who lives nearby and has bought even more saddles than I have during the years. She sympathized with me, as she spends at least as much time as I do buying them, selling them, and beginning a new search. As far as I know, the only saddle she has kept all these years is her Billy Cook.

Reactor Panel “Elegance”
She had none of her own to sell me (she may still have that Reactor Panel, but knows I like a close contact fit). A friend of hers, though, has a 17.5″ Sommer mono flap with a wide tree that’s for sale. I could “keep it” and ride in it for as long as I wanted, because her friend was waiting for a new, custom saddle…of course, she might want the Sommer back, if the new saddle didn’t fit. I understand.
Continue reading →